COVID-19 Business Liability
Questions/Answers on Business Liability and COVID-19 (May,21 2020)
First, it is important to understand the employer risk of liability. Historically, there is very little employer liability from an employee who claims a communicable disease as a workplace injury. In these times, there are no guarantees, but a claim that an employer contracted COVID-19 at work would be extremely difficult. However, this could be dependent upon the precautions and safety standards followed by an employer. For example, if your state has issued guidelines for a safe-work place, and the employer does not follow them - then arguably the employee could attempt to show that the lack of safety caused their injury - in this case COVID-19.
If, as an employer, you have deemed it safe to return to work, and are following all guidelines issued by your state; then you can require employees to return to work. If an employee refuses, because they do not feel safe, you have the option of firing them. (If you have a union, then there would be additional hurdles) So long as the employee is not under a contract, or union, it most likely means they are employed at-will. As an at-will employment, the employer can fire an employee for any reason, so long as it is not illegal. In this case, fear of returning to work, is not in and of itself valid, and the employer could fire the employee. Keep in mind, that currently, fear of contracting COVID-19 is not recognized. But this again is based on precautions the employer has implemented. If you do not have all the safe-guards in place, and the employee says they do not feel safe to return, this could be valid under OSHA, because employers must provide a safe workplace for its employees.
Under the Families First Coronavirus Response Act (FFCRA), all private sector employers with LESS THAN 500 EMPLOYEES, must provide additional emergency leave to employees under certain situations. The situations include: (1) employees who are subject to a government mandated isolation/ quarantine; (2) employees who have been advised by a healthcare provider to self-quarantine; (3) employees who have COVID-19 symptoms and are seeking treatment; (4) employees caring for an individual who is either subject to a government mandated quarantine or were advised by a healthcare provider to self-quarantine; (5) employees caring for their children at home as a result of their child’s school closing; and (6) employees experiencing any other substantially similar condition as certified by the Department of Health and Human Services (“HHS”).
For situations 1-3, full-time employees are eligible for 80 hours (2 work weeks) of paid sick leave under FFCRA at up to 100% of their normal pay (capped at $511/day and $5,110 for the entire 80 hours). For situations 4-6, full-time employees can receive 66% of their normal rate of pay, up to $200 per day (or $2,000 for the entire 80 hours). For an employee who is caring for children at home because of lack of childcare, after exhausting the 80 hours of partially paid leave, they may then opt to utilize Emergency Paid FMLA Leave under the FFCRA, for another 10 weeks (or 12 weeks in total).
A few notes on the FFCRA. While employers must initially cover these payments from their own funds, the cost is offset by refundable tax credits. Employers cannot terminate an employee for using any of these rights set out under FFCRA, as this would be deemed retaliatory, and put the employer at risk. If an employer has under 50 employees, they can request to opt out, but this must be formally done, and an employer must demonstrate that complying would place the business in harm. Lastly, there are exemptions to certain businesses deemed essential. Deathcare, funeral homes, cemeteries, and crematories, are not specifically listed, but the DOL, in an unwritten opinion, has suggested that they would fall under the emergency responder exemption. I do not know if this would carry over to concrete and burial vault manufacturers. The FFCRA is scheduled to last until December 31, 2020.
In regard to denying compensation, it would be based upon the reasoning for the termination. If you are terminating for failure to return to work, despite all safety measures being in place, then as an employer you could challenge unemployment compensation. However, as stated above, if you are denying because of certain rights under the FFCRA, then your business would be at risk and most likely in violation of the FFCRA regulations.
There are fears among businesses that they could be liable, or at least face potential liability, from consumers if they ultimately contract coronavirus. Unfortunately, we do not know how this will ultimately play out once the crisis ends. There are government officials asking for regulations that would prohibit lawsuits based on where / how coronavirus may have been contracted. Historically, lawsuits based on communicable disease, such as coronavirus, are very difficult to prove. The issue of proving exactly where you contracted the disease is almost impossible to prove. However, as stated above in question 1, if a business violates guidelines that are mandated, or possibly even recommended, it could open itself to more potential liability.
As a business, it is important to handle this risk as you would any other risk. Follow all guidelines that would relate to your business. Do not intentionally create a higher risk, by ignoring precautions that are being adopted by others. Also, make sure you have liability insurance for your company, and that acclaim like this, however distant the likelihood may be, would be covered under your policy. This pandemic is unprecedented, and we do not know what we will see after it all settles.
Additional tools available to NCBVA members: